|
|
|
HARDWOOD VS LAMINATES VS CARPETING
Reader Marietta Kuehn asks this question: “I can’t decide if I should
replace my carpeting or refinish the hardwood flooring underneath it.
What are the pros and cons. It’s just my husband and I living here.”
Hardwood floors were the norm until wall-to-wall carpeting swept the
market in the 60’s. The majority of carpet sold today is made of nylon,
and it has greatly improved over the years. But there is a steady trend
back to the look of wood, real and otherwise.
Reasons why we love hardwood are that it adds natural beauty, it is
considered elegant, and it increases the value of our homes. The
intricate grain patterns, and the variety of color in the vast selection
of woods can enrich any space. It looks great with or without the
addition of an area rug. Dusting and damp mopping a properly sealed
floor are enough to maintain it for years. It can be refinished in due
time to bring back its original luster. If properly maintained it can
last a lifetime and beyond.
The downside of hardwood is the expense, although there is a wide range
of prices today. Wood scratches and dents easily, it fades in strong
sunlight, it expands and contracts, and can be water damaged. It needs a
proper sub-floor. And must be nailed or glued onto place.
A less expensive choice is engineered wood flooring. It has real wood on
the surface, with under layers of plywood and fiberboard. It can be
floated over existing flooring and concrete without the need for glue or
nails, and is excellent in higher humidity.
Laminates are the rage because they can be half the price, or less, of
wood floors. Made of bonded cellulose paper, resins, and particleboard,
they look like real wood. But they are scratch resistant, don’t fade,
don’t need polishing, and some have simple locking systems that are easy
for a homeowner to install. They also may be floated over existing
floors or concrete.
Since they aren’t wood, laminates cannot be refinished, and they are not
as easy to repair. Although laminates are family friendly, large dogs
and dragging heavy objects can scratch the surface. Unless you choose
one that has layers that absorb sound, laminates can be noisy.
Carpeting on the other hand readily absorbs clattering sounds, it feels
great underfoot, it warms our homes in winter, and it come in a
limitless array of beautiful colors. It is relatively durable if made of
good quality nylon, wool, or synthetic fibers. But stains can be deadly,
traffic patterns can show a path, and carpeting needs heavy duty
cleaning.
Lots to consider if you are starting over, but for Marietta the choice
to refinish the wood floors wins hands down. If she adds an area rug, it
combines the best of both worlds. With minimal care she can enjoy the
glow of wood surrounding a colorful rug. It’s a design standard with
timeless appeal.
|